Cicero asks "Americans - who are you?"
Do you have an opinion about this subject?, If so, why not share it? Respond to Cicero Or ask your own question!
Should Abortion Be Legal?
Says cicero on January 26, 2008
Is a foetus an actual human being? If it’s not, then how can it have rights? If it has rights, how does it affect the rights of the mother? If she chose to have sex, can she not choose whether or not to keep the resulting life? If she was forced into sex through rape, or there are mental or physical health exceptions, does this not give her the right to terminate the pregnancy?
These are just some of the questions surrounding this emotive of subjects, and there are many arguments for and against abortion, on religious, social, scientific, political and humanitarian grounds.
After more than forty years of debate, the abortion issue remains one of the broader and more controversial societal issues.
We hope that you will join the debate and share your views about this most human of challenges - the bioethics of abortion.
What do you think?
Cicero
Responses to Cicero

Imthefallena7x says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
abortion is murder! you might be killing the one that has the cure for AIDS or for cancer! the one that might actually save your life one day! give the child up for adoption so they can have a family adopt them and love them for who you wouldnt love them for! let a couple complete their family! and especially let that innocent baby live!
Respond to imthefallena7x »
Yaotamashii08 says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal? - Anti-Abortion / Pro-life Short Film (Third Born)
Screened-off in the belly of their mothers, three unborn babies give an account of their time within the confines of the womb. Starting from the point of conception, they chart their development, voicing delight at the discoveries that come with each new week. However, as the thirteenth week approaches the excitement for one soon vanishes. A voice formally brimming with an expectation of life out in the real world, is silenced when it meets a murderous fate, one that will ensure it never leaves the womb alive.
Respond to yaotamashii08 »
Covakid says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
"Contraception: Why Not," by Professor Janet Smith
An amazing, life-changing presentation
Increased Abortions
Contraceptives have launched people on a lifestyle that makes for sex outside of marriage-makes for sex in which babies and bonding are not welcome likelihoods. And when that happens, disaster strikes. People now say...when they're having sex outside of marriage and they get pregnant, what do people say? They use this wonderful phrase: "I got pregnant by accident."
-- free MP3 download --
http://www.janetsmith.excerptsofinri.com
-- FREE Audio CD --
http://www.contraception.excerptsofinri.com
"Contraception: Why Not," by Professor Janet Smith
An amazing, life-changing presentation, NOW available on a FREE CD
One per each new customer (USA ~ Canada ~ Mexico only)
The Connection Between Contraception and Abortion
http://www.omsoul.com/catalog/index.php?target=products&product_id=146"
Sapperbloggs says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
My views, in a nutshell, is that abortion is obviously a polarising argument. It's not a minority that is either for or against abortion, western society is generally split 50/50 on the subject. Some think it is murder, others do not see it this way at all.
Therefore, nobody should be forced to have an abortion that they don't want to have, and likewise, nobody should be forced not to have an abortion that they do want to have. It is the choice of the individual.
Men especially, while they can have an opinion, that is all they can have, because they cannot ever have an abortion.
20,000,000 of the 46,000,000 abortions performed worldwide annually, are performed in countries where abortion is illegal. So don't think for a second that changing the law will stop abortion. It will simply make it unregulated and dangerous, where the rich are the only ones able to afford 'safe' abortions, while the poor are forced to have risky abortions or have children they simply cannot afford to raise.
Arguing abstinence is useless. People do not think about what may happen 9 months later in the heat of the moment. They didn't 50 years ago, and they don't now. A brief look on the US policy of promoting abstinence and as well as a look at the US teen pregnancy rates, backs this up.
If you don't want an abortion, don't have an abortion. But you don't have any right whatsoever to make others miserable for choosing to have one. It takes a lot more guts to admit that you cannot raise a child in the way that they deserve to be raised, than it does to label someone a murderer because they have different views than you do.
Sapperbloggs
Gabriel says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
I agree. Making abortion illegal is going to stop men having sex with women without precautions and getting them pregnant. it's just going to put safe terminations back 30 years into the hands of back street abortionists. frightening thought!!
Respond to gabriel »
Stephenbeadles says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Even if a mother is raped this tragedy does not give her the right to murder an innocent child. Every abortion stops a real heartbeat and measurable brainwaves. This women does not deserve to be punished for anything but what about the child? The are thousands of parents wanting to adopt a child of their own.
Respond to stephenbeadles »Kalinka says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Why would you consider bearing the child of her rapist as anything OTHER than a punishment for the woman?
Respond to kalinka »
Felicellena says
Re: Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
To the person who wrote that if the mother gives birth to the baby conceived through a rape. The person believes that the mother would be punished. I respect your perspective, and when focusing on the mother's point of view, you are correct. I have looked at pictures of aborted fetuses, most as young as only a few weeks. The major organs especially the heart and brain are formed and functioning. To make an informed decision, the mother must look at a sonogram, and pictures of aborted fetuses, and read the stories of men and women who have endured abortions ( Rachael's Vineyard web link).However, the baby would be eliminated for the crime of his father. Is it too much to ask that the mother focus on the baby's chance to live, then give him/her up for adoption?
Respond to felicellena »
Covakid says
Re: Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Hi Kalinka - I was wondering have you seen an abortion? it's a real and painful punishment for the innocent baby.
http://www.cbrinfo.org/ it is really so sad and hurts my heart.
Megan's story - I love my Baby who was Conceived by Rape
http://youtube.com/watch?v=-fw0rYNNvOQ
Many women I have seen have a hidden punishment after having an abortion and few are "Silent no More"
http://youtube.com/watch?v=7BCI2J-MsUg
http://youtube.com/watch?v=6tMBoMiKGSY
http://youtube.com/watch?v=wg7oERk7FkE
Should abortion be done if the pregnancy results from forcible rape?
The simple, most direct answer is “should we kill an innocent baby for the crime of his father?”
Or, another way of saying it, “We don't punish other criminals by killing their children, do we?
Why in this case?”
Deuterotomy 24:16 agrees. I quote: “The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, neither shall the children be put to death for the fathers. Every man shall be put to death for his own sin.”
In over 50% of assault rape pregnancies, the second victim, the mother, does not want to kill her baby. Rather, she needs our compassion, our love, our continuing help and our encouragement. - Dr. John Willke
Stephenbeadles says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Also to add, why is it that abortion is just called abortion? if a man takes a gun and shoots and kills a pregnant women he is charged with double homicide. Why? because it is murder, killing a child is wrong. yes we must respect the rights of women but when she would we give the right for one human to end a another human's life?
Respond to stephenbeadles »Sapperbloggs says
Re: Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
'if a man takes a gun and shoots and kills a pregnant woman'...
Some people see a fetus as an unborn human, and everyone sees a pregnant woman as someone who should be protected, therefore the law (in the US only, I believe) accomodates this belief if somebody kills the mother and unborn baby they have killed two people.
This doesn't mean that there are others who do not share this belief, and it's a ridiculous argument against abortion. Many people also don't see a fetus as a human, and abortion is allowed, by law, to accomodate the beliefs of this very large portion of the community
Jaybones says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
The question should not be, does a fetus have rights, but do the rights of the fetus overrule the rights of the pregnant woman. My thoughts on this were, and still are, influenced by the death of a high school classmate who died from a backalley abortion. I believe that the decision should be made by the woman with the input of her medical professional, her family, and her spiritual advisor.
Since women are going to get abortions whether they are legal or not, I think that it is incumbent upon the society to make that medical procedure as safe as possible. The people that target doctors and picket outside clinics, have driven away many of the best physicians because those physicians don't need the grief. Those that are left are only those that are either truly devoted to the cause, or those that can't find other medical work. So the protesters are actually making a very safe procedure more dangerous. I think these protesters do this because they think the women that get abortions deserve to be punished and not because they care about these women.

Covakid says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Hello Jaybones
"a very safe procedure" It is not safe for the baby, have you seen an abortion? http://www.cbrinfo.org/
There are many Abortion Mills that are not safe and it's a lie
Here is an example Amarillo, TX - Fr. Frank Pavone, National Director of Priests for Life, today commented upon the forced closing of the Center for Women’s Health in Cleveland. The clinic, which performed late-term abortions, failed to have its state license renewed when officials found numerous health and safety violations at the facility. “The shoddy conditions and practices in those facilities have been the dirty little secret of the abortion industry for years,” Fr. Pavone commented. “But it’s being revealed more and more. The more closely health regulators look at these clinics, the more dangers they will find.”
http://www.priestsforlife.org/pressreleases/06-09-15ohioclinic.htm
There was one in New Jersey that was unsteril in so many ways, and it was though a money making machine, but after years of practice got shut down.
Mark123 says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
You are making an unequal comparison, which is why I will disagree with you.
The lifestyle of one person does not override the life of another. And the best medical evidence today is unequivocal: life begins at conception.
Furthermore, the argument that 'abortions will happen anyway' is pretty silly, given that the same logic could be given to make bank robbery, rape and driving on the wrong side of the road legal.
In regards to your friend that died, are you not aware that women die from so-called 'safe' abortion today? And not only that, many are scarred for life, either emotionally or physically - with evidence beginning to mount of the connection between abortion and ectopic pregnancies, as well as breast cancer.
Furthermore, former abortionists will themselves disagree with you about the procedure and the level of 'devotion' towards women themselves. They are actually devoted to one thing: money. Next patient please. Oh you have complications? Too bad. Next patient please.
If I were you I would look at the subject again.
Kalinka says
Re: Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
The link between breast cancer and abortion has been disproven. It's a scare story.
http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/Risk/abortion-miscarriage

Rjhgins says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
A Jewish perspective on abortion
Respond to rjhgins »Timmy says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Really informative about the Jewish side of things. Quite a complex perspective. Very Interesting.
Respond to timmy »
Starlitshores says
Thinking about having an abortion?
Beyond the legality of abortion. beyond the debates, the accusations, the foul language on both sides of the argument...thousands of women contemplate abortion every day and over 4,000 women choose it.
Women do regret abortion. Silentnomore.com and afterabortion.com show innumerable accounts from women that regret their abortions. Many had no idea what abortion really meant. No one was there to say, "Here let me show you the ultrasound of your baby with a heart beat and fingers and toes. Let me help you."
I run a crisis pregnancy website: myspace.com/starlitshores
Here are just a couple of notes I have received from girls and women who have made the painful choice of abortion (these stories are used with permission. The names have been changed to protect privacy):
Yesterday I recieved this message from a beautiful girl. Many blessings to her for sharing her story and allowing me to post it so that it may inspire many to rethink abortion. May her baby Joshua rest in the palm of God's hand and may she find hope, love, and forgiveness.
I had an abortion yesterday...
I asked to see the ultrasound before it happened,
because I have no health insurance,
so I hadn't been to a doctor,
and hadn't had an ultrasound before.
I dont think I will ever get over this.
I have been pro-life for as long as I can remember,
but I thought it would be easier to send my baby's soul back to God to wait until I could afford to support them.
I feel so alone,
and after seeing the baby, MY baby, on the screen,
and then feeling him be sucked from my body,
all I could do was cry "NO, NO, NO........" over and over again while it happened...
It's been about twelve hours...
and I cant stop crying.
I want my baby back, I want MYYY BABY back...........
and because I couldn't ever face placing my newborn child into someone else's arms...
I'll never get to hold my baby,
or see my baby grow...
I've been playing "Run" by Snow Patrol all day...
It was the biggest mistake I've ever made...
I cant go back...
Abortion is wrong...
I saw my little baby move it's little head, and arm,
I will never ever ever forget that image...
I'm so scared...
I want to die,
My baby is gone...........
~Christina
i had an abortion...
i was 110% sure i was gonna have the baby and then realized i was too young nd the dad didnt want it and cut out of my life nd i didnt want to live from pay check to pay check nd raise my child nd have to hear wheres my daddy nd have to say he didnt want you...i know what thats like...
but i did it for my baby nd not me thats what i was thinking then nd realized that thats wrong you dont kill someone for their own good...i regret it nd miss my child everyday...nd i thought i was being a good mother for doin what i was doin because i didnt want my child to grow up how i did but now i know i shouldnt have done it but its already to late...
i remember in the 9th grade we we're told to write a paper nd a speech nd my topic was AGAINST ABORTIONS... i will never forget what i did february 2nd 2005...i made a life out of what i thought was love nd i killed it when all along it was my son nd i loved him...
late at night i look down nd touch my stomach nd wishes he was there nd ache because i know what i have done nd i know that i can never make it right...
i hope nd pray i am forgiven for what i have done nd pray that when its the right time GOD will send me my child...if you have read all of this i would like to thank you for your time...nd i hope you understand why i was so upset...if you need to you can tell my story to help someone maybe a girl like myself.
~Shannon
The abortion took place on May 31, 2002...the worst day of my life...I want others to hear my story because I am soooo sick of people saying that women are not hurt by abortion...
To answer the question: How has abortion affected you?
To many people, this question would be simple to answer. For me, it is complex and hard, not just for the fact that it brings up so many emotions, but because abortion caused a tidal wave of events in my life. Instead of listing off the ways that it has affected me, I find this as an opportunity to share my story, which I think has more depth than a list.
After leaving my parent's house at 17 because I didn't want to follow their rules, I found out that I was pregnant. My boyfriend had taken me to Planned Parenthood because he happened to notice that I hadn't had my period in a couple of months. I had never been so scared when the nurse came in and told me that I was pregnant. I went and got my boyfriend, Kile, from the waiting room and brought him in. As soon as I sat on his lap and started crying, he knew. I struggled with the words, but finally got them out, "I'm pregnant." The very first thing that came out of Kile's mouth was that I was having an abortion. I was in shock and so when the nurse explained the process of a judicial bypass and the different abortion clinics, I just nodded. I pretended for a couple of days that none of it was true but was brought back to reality when Kile handed me the phone and said that 'they' needed to talk to me. 'They' ended up being an attorney's office that Planned Parenthood had given us the number to, and who would help with the Judicial bypass, which was going to be needed because I was underage and I never thought that I would be able to tell my parents about my pregnancy, let alone ask their permission for an abortion.
After 4 days of thinking about being pregnant, I decided that I wanted to keep my baby…but Kile had different plans for me. He grabbed me by the shoulders and yelled: "You're having an abortion, Kristen!!! I refuse to help you out in any way and you won't have anywhere to go because you're not living with me! I do not want a kid!!" The next day, he took me to see the attorney, and not even a week later I was in front of the judge. He granted me the judicial bypass and Kile made the appointment for the abortion that coming Saturday in Saginaw.
May 31st was a rainy, overcast, chilly day. To this day I remember what I was wearing, what the building looked like inside and out, and even how the chairs were set up in the waiting area. After I signed in, I sat in the chair staring at the wall, holding my belly, trying to talk myself into running out of the building…but that thought was interrupted by the nurse saying she was ready for me. They did blood work, then an ultrasound (which they wouldn't let me see), gave me a valium, and had me and another older woman go into a room where the "counseling" took place. WHAT A JOKE!!! The counseling was just prepping us for how the procedure was and how to take care of ourselves for the few days after. They put all the women in a room and one by one called us out to have the procedure done, and as I waited, I listened to the other women talk…it was one ladies 7th abortion…another's 3rd. It surprised me how nonchalantly they talked about such a huge thing. I heard screaming, then silence, and then my name…it was my turn…The nurse had me take my pants and underwear off and my feet in the stirrups. She told me to look straight up at the ceiling and not to the right. The Dr. came in, spread my legs, and started. I screamed and kept trying to put my legs together, but he said that if I didn't stop, he wasn't going to be able to finish it. I reached out for the nurses hand, but she wouldn't hold it. I have never felt so much pain in my life and thought that the noise was almost unbearable. When he was done, I looked over…there it was…a jar with my baby in it, and that's when it hit me…that's my baby in that jar and they're just going to throw it away like it's garbage??!!!
I went to the recovery room and watched as a couple of the girls were crying. I told myself to keep my composure. The minute that I walked out of the clinic and into Kile's car, I fell apart. How could I have just done that!!???? The only support that Kile gave me was some vicodin and then told me to sleep. The next couple of years were filled with self hate…self mutilation, drinking, drugs and one suicide attempt…anything to get my mind off of the abortion.
I know that I will never be the same, but by the grace of God, I found healing. Rachel's Vineyard changed my life! I still do think that a part of me died that day, but another part of me was born at Rachel's Vineyard. I know that my son, Kristopher Daniel, is in Christ's arms, waiting to meet me. I have learned how to use this for the good, but still want people to know that abortion doesn't turn back time…it stops it…it doesn't end your problem…it starts it…and it is never for the better, but only for the worse. So from now on, I will be SILENT NO MORE
~Krysten
Here is another emotional testimony I have received from a woman who has been scarred by abortion. If you are considering an abortion or know someone who is consider this story before you make that fateful choice.
I was 16 when I had my first child. My son was born at 24 weeks. He is 10 now. It was very traumatic at the time but he was a miracle. Afterwards, I wanted to get my tubes tied but no-one would do it for me. When I was 24 I got pregnant while I was on birth control and didn't know I was pregnant. I kept taking it until about two months later when I got sick and had a test done.
When I found out I was devastated. I was told that the birth control I was taking could have caused allot of damage. I was stupid, I chose abortion. I told the father and he wasn't happy, but he supported my decision. I don't know how I went through with it. I did it with support. Afterwards I was traumatized.
All I could think about was: what if I had chose life? I didn't even look at the ultrasound! I hate myself. So...all I can think about is how my life would have been with the child. What it would have looked like. It's too hard to talk about.
So, I chose to give my life to God. I didn't have sex for a year. Then I met my husband Justin. We were married and soon after I was pregnant again. I was still afraid, but I chose life, of course. It was a normal pregnancy. I'd never known how that felt. After having Kaleb, my second son, I had more regret than ever about the abortion.
I still struggle to sleep at night. I still wonder. More than anything, I wish I had known you, my baby. I had no idea, I didn't do any research. Now all I want is to try to stop anyone else from doing it. I am mentally traumatized, and emotionally scarred forever. I realize now that I made the greatest mistake anyone could ever make. I'm glad I have my husband and my son, but I'll never know what could have been.
Sometimes I think I'm no better than a monster, but I love children, my children, and all children. I would never hurt them and I wish I could go back in time. Though I know I'm a good person, what I did haunts me every day and night. To hear someone like you say that God still loves me, and that my child is with Him really touches me. I know I need to move on and heal, I just don't know how. I wonder if I'll still be crying 40 years from now...that ache that won't go away.
~Julia
Please, if you have been through an abortion, visit the websites I mentioned above. They may be able to help with the healing process. Peace and love always.

Starlitshores says
Why I'm Pro-life
At 19 years old my mother chose to give birth to me instead of having an abortion as many suggested. They suggested this so that she could start a life free of a physically and verbally abusive relationship, avoid being a single parent, go to college, have a career and later get remarried and have children with a man she loved. Though life was not easy for a while (whose life is?) she choose to let me continue living.
Now I am 20, older than she was when she had me. I have graduated as valedictorian, am a history and creative writing major on a full college scholarship, and am getting married next summer. My life is worth living!..despite what many told my mother. And so are the lives of thousands of unborn babies scheduled to die today, no matter their means of conception or their abilities.
My mother is remarried and has just graduated from college (she went back to school to be a teacher). Maybe some will say that this is the extreme case and all women will not eventually be able to fulfill their dreams like she did, but I am here and alive to say that it is possible.
But my personal story is not the only reason that I am so involved in the abortion issue...in fact when I was in my early years of high school I was very pro-choice. I knew that I could never have an abortion myself…but who was I to tell others what to do?
But soon after my freshman year in high school I had some wonderful teachers who showed me a video on the realities of abortion...since then for the past 7 years I have done a TON of research on the issue….I've read pro-choice literature such as Moments on Maple Ave, Planned Parenthood's endless bound of literature, etc. Pro-life literature and A LOT of fetal development information…and what I've learned makes me realize, not only the reality and sanctity of every human life in the womb, but of the horrible violence and murder of a baby that is abortion.
I've realized that when one accepts that life can be killed because it's inconvenient or "unworthy", there's too many people, or whatever road you choose to go down to validate it—you're accepting the fact that all life isn't as sacred as you held it before.
Therefore, the elite themselves have convinced the public we're just a bunch of animals that have to be culled off in the same way when there's too many of us. Then we start to accept it. When people accepted the killing of children, babies, people...that was the start of it—Dehumanization."
I am a history major and whenever my fellow majors and I learn about a horrible event in history such as the holocaust or slavery people always say things like, "Oh, I would have stood up against that!" "I would have been an abolitionist" or "I would never have condoned the murder of millions in Europe!" But what I want to say to them is "Don't you care about the 50 million babies slaughtered since 1973 in this country?! I would also like to think I would have stood up for the helpless throughout history and that is what I am trying to do in the present.
The little human beings in the womb have no voice….no one is telling their mothers, "look let me show you a photo of what your baby looks like now.." or "Here let me give you an ultrasound so you may see your baby move" "Or let me help you in your 'choice' to show you what you are doing, your baby's heart has already started beating 18 days after conception." I want to be that voice…a voice of truth to the reality of life so that mothers may not make the horrible choice of killing their unborn because they think it is just a bunch of meaningless cells or they don't have any other options.
One of my favorite quotes is "Whoever saves one life saves the world entire"~The Talmud. I truly believe that. If by making all these videos, volunteering time and money to pro-life causes, writing about the unborn, and public speaking in defense of pre-born babies, I can save one life…it would all be worth it. If I can save one woman from the agony of abortion and one beating heart from being torn apart…what greater thing could I achieve in my life?

Starlitshores says
Regarding "saving" children by aborting them/ Mercy Killing
Regarding saving children from abuse, neglect, disease, a handicap etc. by taking their life by abortion-------
By saying that one is saving children from tough family situations, and those who may be born with drug addictions or HIV or a handicap, you are also saying that these children are less human or less deserving of life than other quote normal babies.
Before we try to save those babies by killing them, maybe we should think of the beauty of their life, of the love of their friends, and their future impact on the world. Are the children with the above conditions who live outside of the womb, who are newborns, toddlers, teens, etc less worthy to live because their lives seem much harder than our own. How many of us can really say they should not be alive?
A tough family situation, a handicap, having HIV or a pre-natal addiction to drugs does not doom a person's life...Are we willing to tell all those people who have been born quote abnormal that they don't deserve to live or that their life is not as worthy or meaningful as our own?
That it would have been better that they hadn't been born? I believe those people would disagree. If only we all could look at other human beings no matter their race, health, sex, ability, etc. and say, You are a human being. I acknowledge that you are alive and that you have the same right to live as I have. Though I may not understand you, I respect you as a fellow human on this planet trying to overcome adversity just as I am, trying to find happiness just as I am, crying and laughing just as I am, and above all else and most importantly you are alive just as I am alive.
Starlitshores says
Regarding Rape, Incest, and the Life of the Mother
------Regarding Rape, Incest, and the life of the mother-------
I, myself, was pro-choice for years. I felt that it was wrong as simply a from of birth control, but that in the hard cases it should be allowed. The thing to remember, however, is that in cases such as rape and incest, the child conceived is still present...
Rape and incest are some of the worst, most violating, harmful events a woman can go through. No one can ever justify them. However, the life conceived in this horrible act is innocent. The rapist often gets away or is given jail time. His child is given the death penalty.......
No woman should ever have to make that choice. No woman should ever be violated against her will. But the biology--the life--of the baby conceived is no different than any other baby conceived.
Also, many women who have an abortion after a rape still feel immense regret and go through the same feelings of rape as they go through the painful act of abortion. Many women who allow the child to live feel that they have been able to rise above the evil act of rape by having their child. One rape survivor told me, "Once I found out I was pregnant after it (the rape) I transformed from simply a victim to a mother. Now I have a little baby girl. Her life means more than the act of her father."
Nearly 1% of women getting abortions have been raped and we must always show them love and care, but if you realize that the child is a human being how can killing him or her make the rapist act less painful?
................And those instances where the mother's life is actually in danger—where the baby or her will die--usually only occur at 5 months gestation or after where, if the baby was delivered and not killed through abortion, he or she would have a least a chance at living.
~~~I do realize that other instances, such as an ectopic pregnancy--where there is no chance of survival for the baby and the mother's life is in danger-- require different attention. In these cases the baby can be removed from the mother, and, as he or she is too young to survive outside the womb will pass away
......I am in no way condemning those 1% of women who have to make these tough choices in cases of rape, incest, and illness. It is not my place to judge them. My goal is to spread the reality of life in the womb to the other 99% of women who may seek abortion and their friends, relatives, boyfriend, husbands etc.
Between 1/3 and 1/4 of all babies conceived are aborted. These little lives are snuffed out. If only we could all know the beauty that is every human life. ---------

Starlitshores says
Abortion, the reality (with quotes from abortionists)
Here is a grapic video of the reality of abortion. The only way one can truly understand abortion is to see abortion.
This video is medically accurate. By examining a fetal delopment text one can see that the babies (most aborted babies are over 7 weeks old) shown in this video are the ages reported.
Even abortionists admit that abortion is the taking away of life. (clinicquotes.com)
"When you do a D & C most of the tissue is removed by the Olden forceps or ring clamp and you actually get gross parts of the fetus out. So you can see a miniature person so to speak, and even now I occasionally feel a little peculiar about it because as a physician I'm trained to conserve life and here I am destroying life." Dr. Benjamin Kalish, abortionist
It's a central question in the abortion debate- does abortion take a human life? Some abortion providers give surprising answers to this question.
"I have the utmost respect for life; I appreciate that life starts early in the womb, but also believe that I’m ending it for good reasons.... So yes, I end life, but even when it’s hard, it’s for a good reason." (1)
Boston Abortion Doctor
"If I see a case...after twenty weeks, where it frankly is a child to me, I really agonize over it because the potential is so imminently there...On the other hand, I have another position, which I think is superior in the hierarchy of questions, and that is "who owns this child?" It's got to be the mother." (2)
The late Dr. James MacMahon, who performed D&X (also known as Partial Birth) abortions
"I dare say any thinking sensitive individual can't not realize that he is ending life or potential life." (3)
Abortionist Dr. Charles Bender
"A lot of people say they're killing their baby. You get a lot of that. Some people afterwards get very upset and say 'I killed my baby.' Or even before, they say 'My circumstances are such that I can't keep it, but I'm killing my baby.' They wouldn't rather have the baby, and give it up for adoption either. If you go into that with them they will say that they could never do that...and yet they still consider it killing the baby...well, they are killing a baby. I mean, they are killing something that would develop into maturity..." (4)
Clinic Worker Dora Greenwald
"When you do a D & C most of the tissue is removed by the Olden forceps or ring clamp and you actually get gross parts of the fetus out. So you can see a miniature person so to speak, and even now I occasionally feel a little peculiar about it because as a physician I'm trained to conserve life and here I am destroying life." (5)
Dr. Benjamin Kalish, abortionist
"In the beginning I was mixed up because I was taught by the Hippocratic Oath not to take a life." (6)
Abortionist Michael Christie
"It [abortion] goes against all things which are natural. It's a termination of a life, however you look at it." (7)
Abortionist Robert Harris
"[The author] said "Is this a fair way of expressing what you have just said, Doctor? You tell the mother "because your baby is defective, you have the right to kill it or not to kill it. If you choose to kill it, I will do the killing." "Of course," he [the abortionist] said. "There is no other way to say it and be honest."
"It [abortion] is a form of killing. You're ending a life."
Abortion Advocate and President of the National Coalition of Abortion Providers, Ron Fitzsimmons
"No one, neither the patient receiving the abortion, nor the person doing the abortion, is ever, at any time, unaware that they are ending a life..." Abortion provider William F Harrison, MD
“We know that it is killing, but the states permit killing under certain circumstances.” Dr. Neville Sender, founder of Metropolitan Medical Service, an abortion clinic in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
"And then to see, to be with somebody while they're having the injection when they're twenty or twenty-four weeks, and you see the baby moving around, kicking around, as this needle goes into the stomach, you know."
Clinic worker Susan Lindstrom, M.S.W.

Starlitshores says
Definition of Human life
The definition of human life is truly the core of the entire abortion issue. The question of when does life begin has, in fact, never been decided official by the court of law. Because the court of 1973 could not come to a conclusion on this issue they decided to leave this determination up to the mother and the doctor. Since 1973, however, much more medical information about the fetus and embryo has been discovered and I would argue that if the court truly looked into the reality of human life…it would come to realize that human life can only begin at conception. Here, is why:
Let us begin with how many may define the beginning of life.
One definition is that birth is the beginning of human life. But is the action of giving birth truly the creation of life? Does something magical happen at this moment? No. Some say that God puts the soul into a baby the moment he or she is born. But I would ask, "Where does this wisdom you argue as fact come from? What proof are you using? What about the fact that newborn babies recognize the voice of their mothers and fathers, can learn in the womb, and are comforted by positions, sounds, and feelings that resemble life in the womb once they are born? The moment before birth the child is the same being as the moment after.
Other people define life or personhood as beginning when the baby would be able to survive outside of the womb. But I would argue this age of which many call "the age of viability," changes often with the improvement of technology. Babies have been known to survive outside the womb as early as 5 months gestation, so what about 4 and a half months or even 3 and a half. No matter the age, the child is the same being with the same DNA, just younger.
Also how can we say that a baby's dependency on the mother dictates his or her personhood while a new born is also completely dependant, unable to survive on his or her own? Thus by this definition a human would not be a person until after infancy and probably after childhood, when he is more "viable" for life independent from others.
So if we reject that being viable is what makes a child alive does life begin when an unborn baby looks like a baby or acts like a baby? What about the child shown in this video at 12 week? Or the 8 week baby? The toes and hands and eyes are clearly distinguishable. Do these look like babies? How can you look at a little 6 to 7 week being and say, "You are a nothing but a meaningless blob of cells?"
As seen in the ultrasound of a 10 week baby:
the child moves almost constantly. According to a study by the University hospital of Groningen in the Netherlands, unborn babies are never still for more than 13 minutes at a time during the 8 to 19 week stage. They move arms and legs, suck, swallow, jump, and even have the hiccups beginning in the later weeks of the first trimester. Therefore with what wisdom will we draw this line of what is a living baby while the baby does so much in the womb?
Some define life as a heart beat. In this video babies as early as 6-7 weeks are shown with beating heart in ultrasound.
The embryo's heart begins to beat at 18 to 21 days after conception, before a woman even knows she is pregnant.
So is this a safe or wise line to draw?-The heart beat? Well what about the second before the heart beats? What about the minute hour or day before? The child's substance is the still present with unique human DNA separate from the mother and the father. At the moment of conception the baby's sex, hair color, appearance-- every biological part and process of the baby has been set.
A human being has been created.
Even abortionists accept this:
One doctor quotes, "I have the utmost respect for life; I appreciate that life starts early in the womb, but also believe that I’m ending it for good reasons.... So yes, I end life, but even when it’s hard, it’s for a good reason"(Cheryl Alkon "Confessions of an Abortion Doctor" Boston Magazine December 2004)
Starlitshores says
Few late term babies are aborted right? Wrong. CDC reports 8,000 to 10,000 per year.
No one will dispute that most abortions occur in the first trimester thus, many doctors perform only first trimester abortions or almost all first trimester abortions. HOWEVER:
According to the United States Center for Disease control (http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/ss5212a1.htm) in a survey of only 37 of the 50 states.
In the year 2000:
71,553 abortions were performed at 13-21+ weeks of gestation.
8,826 of these occurred at 21+ weeks.
A 21 week baby may be killed on one floor of a hospital because he is "unwanted" while on the next floor down a wanted 21 week premature baby is saved by medical intervention because she is "wanted."
Many use the excuse that these abortions are done for medical reasons. But abortion is not safer than birth. No one is saying that a woman at 21 weeks who has been in an accident or who is diagnosed with a possible fatal disease should be forced to carry her baby and risk death (though I know many women who would) but why not remove the baby and try to save him or her instead of killing the child by abortion? This is insane. Yes, the chances of survival are much slimmer for a 5 month baby than a 9 month baby but at least the little human would be given a chance!
Also, many of the babies killed at this stage have been diagnosed with Down syndrome, spina bifida, or other such diseases. This is eugenics at it's prime.
What is the difference of killing this premature baby inside the womb or outside? Would we condone infanticide or childhood murder of these babies?
If the American public knew that more than 8,826 babies outside the womb were killed every year, there would be an outrage! If one child dies of lead poisoning it makes the national news. Why doesn't aborting late term babies bother us? I think many people do not realize abortion's reality.
Kalinka says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Of course abortion should be legal. To decide otherwise is to force women into unwanted motherhood, and to take away their most basic right, to determine what goes on within their own bodies. Abortion is the last resort of a woman whose life is spinning out of control due to an unwanted pregnancy. Frankly, a woman who really wants an abortion will find a way, legal or not. Drive it into the back streets and you condemn woman to injury, infection and possible death. You make orphans of the children she may already have. You make unwilling and scared mothers out of women too young to bring up a child.
To those of you who would provide abortion only in the circumstances of rape or potential maternal death: do you mean to punish women for being sexual beings? Because the foetus is qualitively no different in either case.
I would suggest to pro-life men that they either become fastidious about contraception, or that they practice what they freely preach to others and abstain from sexual intercourse.

Covakid says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
"Prayerfully Pro-choice"
I remember being out at the abortion mill one day and somebody was holding a sign that said “Prayerfully Pro-choice.” It is not possible, if they were praying to the same God that you and I believe in, that they could ever have come to such a conclusion. So one needs to ask, “Who are they serving?” Jesus said, “You cannot serve two masters.” Anyone who claims to be even Christian, let alone Catholic, and be pro-abortion at the same time is a hypocrite and a liar. You cannot be Catholic or even Christian and call yourself pro-abortion; it is not possible. God is the Author of life. One cannot say that they believe in God, Who is Life itself, and then choose death; it is not a possibility; it is not an option. It does not matter what they want to call themselves, the fact of the matter is that they have given themselves over to the devil and they have chosen evil over good; they have chosen injustice over righteousness; they have chosen death over life; they have chosen the curse over the blessing; they have chosen Satan over God. - Quote Fr. Robert Altier
www.desertvoice.excerptsofinri.com

Covakid says
Re: Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
My previous Movie Upload failed -
"Prayerfully Pro-choice"
http://youtube.com/watch?v=JYykmxt8DhE

Angelasmith says
The Truth about Abortion (WARNING: graphic abortion photos)
My video is graphic and only for mature individuals. I am anti-abortion. I wish to help the Center for Bio-Ethical Reform (CBR), and I feel my video will help the cause. I am very pleased with what CBR is working toward, and they have my full support. www.abortionNO.com
I am not looking for a debate or cruel comments. I only want to show you my video. If you have questions, CBR will be happy to answer them. Visit them online. Keep an open mind when watching my video. The tears I've cried from deeply researching abortion over the past several years of my life are nothing compared to the pain abortion has caused worldwide. Please open up your heart and mind to see abortion for what it really is. Thank you.
For Facebook members, visit the group.
I am a soldier in the war against abortion.
I have heard several comments since posting my video on various sites. A few have stated that "a very small percentage of abortions are late term". This is true. The percentage looks small; however, the number does not.
According to Wikipedia in 2003, 4.2% of abortions were from 16 to 20 weeks, and 1.4% were at or after 21 weeks.
In 1997, the Guttmacher Institute estimated the number of abortions in the U.S. past 24 weeks to be 0.08%, which is approximately 1,032 per year.
Which means, at least 1,032 viable babies, fetuses, whatever you want to call them, are being killed each year. Is that "nothing", like I've heard? How can anyone overlook their pain? 0.08% may look small and sound good when defending abortion, but remember, that is still 1,032 viable lives.
When a newborn is killed by his or her mother, the news covers it from top to bottom. One life taken away is too many. Why should abortion be any different?
Akachoiceaddict says
Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
I believe that abortion should be legal simply because forcing a woman to have a child does not have anything to do with taking responsibility and everything to do with punishment that overreaches its bounds. And yet, I have never heard, in my entire life before, of anyone being punished for nine months and beyond for something that did not happen on purpose.
Respond to akachoiceaddict »Sheri says
No, not even if the babies father is a rapist. I do not believe in punishing the child for the sins of the father.
Respond to sheri »Kalinka says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Do you then believe in punishing the woman for the sins of her rapist? Becasue that it what it amounts to...
Respond to kalinka »Akachoiceaddict says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Yes, I believe abortion should be legal, especially in cases of rape, since I think it's barbaric to punish a woman by taking away her choices twice.
Respond to akachoiceaddict »Yodavater says
Elective abortion is the moral equivalent of child sacrifice ceremonies of some ancient tribes, IMO, except that it is done for individual, rather than tribal gain.
As to your question about a human fetus being an "actual human being", one need only look in any dictionary or other standard reference source to confirm that. "Human being" is simply the vernacular equivalent of the scientific label "Homo sapien", the species to which we all belong.
Of course, simply being a member of our species does not endow us with any particular legal rights. Those must be awarded by the arbitrary action of our government, unfortunately.
Timmy says
Of course it should be legal. a fetus shares the rights of the mother who decides ultimately if it should be born or not. you can argue, if you believe in God, that he decides, or you can look at the practical reality of a person's life and see if a child is a realistic option for the mother. If she is in a position where a child can have a resonable shot at life then she should take on the responsibility of her sexual actions, (assuming they were voluntary) if not, why put a child through hell?
Respond to timmy »Timmy says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
i think the stuff i read by alpha about Blavatsky and karma has made me think again!!!!
Respond to timmy »Georanne says
It should be legal, if the woman's physical or mental health is in jeopardy, or if she has been raped.
Respond to georanne »Charlene says
Absolutely!! Whether or not you actually believe in it, to make it illegal delights the criminal mind with all of the creative ways they can make money while not knowing what they are doing. The results are far far worse than abortion.
Respond to charlene »Eagle2 says
I do not agree with intentionally killing a form of life, even if it is a foetus. It's too easy for the parents to give up and shirk their responsibilities, putting their own desires first. But there is also the difficult scenario of a pregnancy that is the result of rape. Are we heading into controversial territory by suggesting it could be the mother-to-be's karma? Obviously that won't be the situation in every case of this ghastly crime. I'd like to know what the esoteric standpoint is on that.
Respond to eagle2 »Artsalive says
This should NOT be a government matter. It is a medical decision. Do we have to have legislation to get an organ or mend a broken bone.
Respond to artsalive »Alpha says
A quote from Madam Blavatsky:
"Our philosophy goes so far as to say that if the penal code of most countries punishes attempts at suicide, it ought to doubly punich foeticide as an attempt at double suicide...The crime committed lies precisely in the willful and sinful distruction of life, and the interference with the operations of nature, hence with Karma--that of the mother and the would-be future human being." HPB Collected Writings V.p.107/8
HPB also said: "Thus in cases of abortion...nature's original design to create a perfect human being has been interrupted... It is a violation of the laws of harmony of nature, though it be so decreed by those of Karma--every time than the astral monad, instead of running down to the end of its natural period of time in a body--finds itself violently thrown out of it by early death or accident or is compelled, in consequence of it's unfinished task to reappear on earth again in order to complete the unfinished task. Thus it must try a second time to carry out the purpose of the creative intelligence" Ibid VII. p178/9.
I am suprised that none of the comments so far have addressed the life of the unborn foetus. The convenience of the woman is not the only factor at play. If a soul has begun to overshadow the foetus, then that living being has rights of its own, and there are Karmic consequences for both the unborn baby that has it's life cut short, and the mother that terminates the life. For nine months, the mother has exclusive custody of the child, but beginning at birth, the father is also obligated by law and Karma to protect that life. He can't kill a two day old baby because he doesn't want to deal with it. And there is no difference in the degree of Spirit between a two day old baby and an 8 1/2 month old foetus.
Shame on Theosophists who are so attached to left-wing politics that they stand up for the rights of animals and trees, but defend abortion. If the pregnancy threatens the life or sanity (rape, medical complications, etc...) of the mother, then there is another law that intercedes--the moral right to defend oneself against attack or threat. But, the inconvenience of a pregnancy is not an adequate justification.
Timmy says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
This is fascinating. I looked her up. Fascinating woman. I didn't know they wrote about abortion in the 19th century. interesting stuff about the karma of it all!!
Respond to timmy »Millo says
Open and honest reasoning and debate is a good way to reach higher truths.
Respond to millo »Richard01 says
Largly I agree. At the end of the day itis the mother that should have the say. It is her body, and the rest of her life. But lets not loose sight that there is a male in this process too, that can be very emotionally involved. All attempts need to be made to involve him in this process. There is more to this situation than mere physics.
Respond to Richard01 »Richard01 says
Some say that the the soul consciousness is received into the body upon first breath, thus receiving the astrological signature too. That the time before this moment is celluar consciousness that is building up the body so to be able to recieve the soul consciousness.
Considering the far reaching affects of giving birth to a child, I think both parents should have a say in whether a pregnancy is kept or not. So abortion should be legal, but not trivialised.Sound knowledge and counsel needs to be made available so all parties can make an informed decision.

Zoisite888 says
Abortion should be legal. It is really a decision for the mother to make. The decision is very personal with many factors that cannot be judged by another. It could be perhaps a guided deision under supervision and with counselling.
Respond to zoisite888 »
Covakid says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
Does a woman have the right to choose abortion?
It’s an effective question, to be sure. But your first response could well be, “Well, what is her choice?”
When a woman is pregnant, she’s going to have a baby. I’m a physician, and I’ve never yet examined a woman who was only a little bit pregnant. This just happens to be a progressive, nine-month procedure. So what is her choice?
Her only choice is, how is the baby coming out...alive or dead; in many pieces, or whole?
And so her choice is a choice to kill...for life or death. It’s my hope and prayer that she’d made a choice for life. And we can help her by loving both mother and baby. I’d like you to think about that. -- Dr. John Willke
http://www.lifejewels.excerptsofinri.com/life-jewels-vol-1.html#23
http://www.lifejewels.excerptsofinri.com/audio/life_jewels/vol_1/23-right-to-choose.wma
Juzwick says
Abortion should be up to the mother. She should have the option to keep or to abort.
Respond to juzwick »Juzwick says
Re: Re: Should Abortion Be Legal?
That about sums up the discussion.
Respond to juzwick »Do you feel strongly about this subject?
If so, Respond to Cicero
or Express your opinion or viewpoint now!
Other questions
"Quantum leaps! "
'The finest emotion of which we are capable is the mystic emotion. Herein lies the germ of all art and all true science.' Albert Einstein Whereas before I sought the answers to life's great questions in religious or my ...
Says Cicero on July 5, 2008"More gun control, or should we all be armed?"
Do we really need more gun control, or should we all be armed? According to Amnesty, more than 1000 people worldwide are dying from gun violence every day. We all know from the only US government statistics we have that ...
Says Cicero on March 25, 2008"Global warming or a New Ice Age? "
Hardly a day goes by without another news article or website report about climate change and global warming. And just as we were getting used to the idea of the CO2 green house effect, (extinction of the polar bears, Mediterra ...
Says Cicero on March 25, 2008"Americans - who are you?"
One of the most interesting blogs I came across this week was an invitation by a blogger for people outside of the USA to tell us who they think Americans are, culture, politics, moral standing etc. As American culture has ...
Says Cicero on March 25, 2008"Cosmetic Surgery – The price of getting on in life?"
The ever increasing commercially driven pressures that our society puts on women to be beautiful (even though that means blonde and thin), is resulting in huge increases in cosmetic surgical procedures. There were over 10 mill ...
Says Cicero on March 25, 2008Latest Activity
August 5, 2008
11:52 - Geoffstray responded to Timmy on "Re: 2012 - A Five-Minute Summary"
July 11, 2008
12:16 - Timmy responded to Geoffstray on "2012 - A Five-Minute Summary"
July 5, 2008
12:23 - Cicero says "Quantum leaps! "
April 15, 2008
20:17 - Darayavahush responded to Cicero on "Global warming or a New Ice Age? "
April 7, 2008
20:50 - Imtwitchie responded to Cicero on "What’s wrong with America?"
Active users in this discussion
- starlitshores ( 7 posts )
- covakid ( 6 posts )
- timmy ( 4 posts )
- kalinka ( 4 posts )
- akachoiceaddict ( 2 posts )
- sapperbloggs ( 2 posts )
- juzwick ( 2 posts )
- stephenbeadles ( 2 posts )
- Richard01 ( 2 posts )
- imthefallena7x ( 1 post )
- PeterHowe ( 1 post )
- eagle2 ( 1 post )
- jaybones ( 1 post )
- gabriel ( 1 post )
- mark123 ( 1 post )
- zoisite888 ( 1 post )
- artsalive ( 1 post )
- yodavater ( 1 post )
- angelasmith ( 1 post )
- millo ( 1 post )
- felicellena ( 1 post )
- rjhgins ( 1 post )
- alpha ( 1 post )
- georanne ( 1 post )
- yaotamashii08 ( 1 post )
- cicero ( 1 post )

